04.26 pm, Sunday April 04 2010

Internet without laws 'a recipe for anarchy'

15:30 AEST Thu Apr 1 2010
By Matt Bachl and Henri Paget, ninemsn
VIEWS: 0
| FLOCKS: 0
| comments0 comments so far
Communications minister Stephen Conroy. (AAP)
Communications minister Stephen Conroy. (AAP)

Communications minister Stephen Conroy has defended Australia's proposed internet filter by arguing that allowing websites to remain uncensored is a "recipe for anarchy".

In an interview with Fairfax Media, Senator Conroy said that the internet was not "special" and should be censored in the same way as books, films and newspapers.

"This argument that the internet is some mystical creation that no laws should apply to, that is a recipe for anarchy and the wild west," he said.

"I believe in a civil society and in a civil society people behave the same way in the physical world as they behave in the virtual world."

His comments come amid growing debate over the issue of online censorship, which has been fuelled by the rise in Facebook tribute page attacks both in Australia and overseas.

At least some of the vandalism — known online as "trolling" — is linked to the websites 4chan and Encyclopedia Dramatica, both of which are set to be banned under Senator Conroy's internet filter.

It is believed "trolls" sometimes use these websites as gathering points to launch attacks on Facebook tribute pages.

TROLLING

Trolling first gained notoriety in the Australian press in February after the alleged stabbing death of 12-year-old Queensland schoolboy Elliot Fletcher.

Vandals defaced his Facebook tribute page with photographs of bestiality and murder. One picture showed Elliot's head with the words "woot, I'm dead" above it.

OPINION: Why you shouldn't feed trolls

The attacks continued last month when trolls attacked Facebook memorial pages for dead Bundaberg girl Trinity Bates.

Since then, several more similar vandalism attacks have occurred — including on pages for NSW surfer Saxon Bird and Mudgee teenager Michelle Morrissey.

Now the US and the UK have joined calls for online social networks to strike out against troublemakers after dead teenagers in those countries were mocked in similar attacks.

NBC's TODAY show in the US featured a special segment on the trolling following the suicide of popular high school student Alex Pilkington last Sunday.

Trolls attacked her tribute page — not hosted on Facebook but by another website called Formspring — in the hours after her death.

New York police are investigating the messages, with some in her community calling for the trolls to be prosecuted.

Ms Pilkington also received harassing internet messages before her suicide, but her parents say she was in therapy about other issues for some time.

CRACKDOWN

In the wake of the Pilkington attack, Formspring changed the way messages were published. Page administrators now have the ability to decline or allow anonymous comments.

Many say this is the sort of capability Facebook should implement. The website on Tuesday sent a memo to users explaining how to fight back against the vandals.

"In light of these events, we wanted to remind you of the different options available to page administrators to help you moderate the content on your page," the memo said.

"Ban fans that are being abusive. If a fan of your page is repeatedly posting inappropriate content, you can go beyond reporting the fan by banning them from your page by following these instructions."

Users were also reminded how to remove photographs and videos posted by trolls.

The family of Charlotte Wilson, a 16-year-old British student killed in a car accident, said their complaints to Facebook had fallen on deaf ears.

"We've complained to Facebook ... these are cruel and wicked things, just sick and twisted," Charlotte's aunt Sharon Brennan was quoted in the Yorkshire Post as saying.

Trolls infiltrated Charlotte's page with photographs, including one of Jim Carrey sticking his head out of a window with the message "Your dead LOL" above it.

The same image was posted on Saxon Bird's tribute page and has been linked to 4chan.

Ninemsn gathered evidence last month that members of 4chan orchestrated attacks against Trinity Bates' tribute page.

"Help us honor and cherish the memory of Trinity Bates RIP girl," a 4chan user wrote.

Earlier, another user wrote: "You'll have to do some subtle trolling/grieving if you want to get in to the Rest in Peace Elliott Fletcher group without being banned on spot".

FILTER

4chan and Encyclopedia Dramatica — both of which contain obscene material — were included on a purported list of websites set to be banned under Australia's proposed internet filter, which was leaked online last year.

In the Fairfax interview with Senator Conroy, he said his goal with the filter was to "ensure that particularly children ... don't stumble across" child pornography, bestiality, extreme violence and pro-rape websites.

"If we know there are 355 websites today that have child pornographic images on it, should we say well we're not going to do anything about it?" he said.

He admitted that the filter would not block the spread of such material over P2P file sharing services.

The government plans to introduce legislation for the filter within weeks.

 
SHARE:
MESSENGER
FACEBOOK
MORE
Blog on Spaces
Add to delicious
Add to Digg
Share on MySpace
?
Share, bookmark, and save your favourite ninemsn articles and features.  Learn more.

Most popular

 Oil leaking from ship aground in QldA vessel aground on the Great Barrier Reef and leaking oil is in danger of breaking apart, the Queensland government says.
 Five charged in US child gang-rape caseTwo adults and three juveniles have been charged with gang-raping a seven-year-old girl, sold by her 15-year-old stepsister during a party.
 Plane crash lands on Hobart highwayA pilot has crash-landed his small plane on a busy Hobart road.
 Woman's body found on Iron Cove BridgeA woman found dead in the middle of Sydney's Iron Cove Bridge on Sunday morning does not appear to have been the victim of a car accident, police say.
 Four die in LA restaurant shootingA gunman has opened fire inside a Middle Eastern restaurant in the North Hollywood district of Los Angeles, killing four people and wounding another.
 Harley rider injured in Nullabor, WAA female motorcyclist has been airlifted to Perth after losing control of her Harley-Davidson bike in wet conditions in the Nullarbor.
 Child star stalked by Facebook pedophilesThe Facebook page of a British child star has been the subject of attention from pedophiles, says the girl's mother.
 Man with half a body 'fathered child'A man with only half a body is waiting on test results to find out if he is a father.
 Handcuffed NY schoolgirl 'sues police'A 12-year-old New York schoolgirl who was arrested and handcuffed for doodling on her classroom desk is suing police for US$1m (A$1.08m), according to reports.
 Mother of teen murdered in Goa to testifyThe mother of Scarlett Keeling, the British teenager killed in India's resort state of Goa, will be asked to testify in the trial of two men accused of her death starting next week, a lawyer said.
Kenny Easterday. (TLC)Odds defiedMan with half a body claims he fathered fiancee's child. Charlie Sheen. (AAP)Walk outSheen tells friends he's set to leave Two and a Half Men. Kevin Rudd (AAP)'Redneck' furyAlabama residents demand Kevin Rudd issue an apology. Anna Paquin.Shock disclosureEngaged actress Anna Paquin comes out for TV campaign. The ArcelorMittal Orbit.Twisting towerLondon to build 115m tall tower sculpture for the Olympics. The excited punter. (BBC)Coarse racing VIDEO: Swearing punter hijacks live news report.
advertisement
Bride's worst nightmare Woman diagnosed with cancer on the day after her wedding ... read more
Cuffed to a poleSchoolgirl, 12, to sue New York police over punishment for desk scribble
You need the latest version of Flash Player.
Enjoy the most vivid content on the web
Watch video without extra features
Interact with applications on your favourite sites
Upgrade now

page complete
Other ninemsn businesses: iSelect RateCity
© 1997-2010 ninemsn Pty Ltd - All rights reserved