Amazon's Ingenious Scheme to Undermine Black Friday

Amazon isn't just taking the pain out of Black Friday shopping. It's undermining the holiday completely.
A conveyor system at an Amazon Fulfilment Center in Tracy California.
04 Aug 2015, Tracy, California, USA --- Products are moved on a conveyor system at an Amazon Fulfilment Center in Tracy, California, August 3, 2015. REUTERS/Robert Galbraith --- Image by © ROBERT GALBRAITH/Reuters/CorbisRobert Galbraith/Reuters/Corbis

Depending upon your outlook, Black Friday is either a time-honored US shopping holiday or the miserable nadir of American consumer culture. Whichever lens you choose to view it through, there's no denying that Black Friday is huge. Adobe's Digital Index shows that last year’s Black Friday holiday set a record, with consumers spending $2.4 billion online, a 24 percent increase from 2013. This year, according to estimates, that trend line is still going up: eMarketer projects a 5.7 percent gain in retail sales, with e-commerce continuing to grow in the double digits, as it's done for several years.

Of all the retailers hoping to capitalize on this trend, Amazon is by far the most well-positioned. This week, on the heels of launching a Black Friday online store well ahead of the actual day, the company said that its holiday deals would start rolling out as early as tomorrow—a full week ahead of Black Friday, the day after Thanksgiving here in the US. The company had eight days of Black Friday deals last year, too, but this year it's giving the promotion an even bigger push: new deals will be added as often as every five minutes on Amazon’s dedicated Black Friday page, twice the rate of last year. In 2014, Amazon offered three “coveted” deals of the day starting on Thanksgiving at midnight, as well as three more on Black Friday; this year, it’s offering ten at the stroke of midnight on both days.

Plus, Amazon is giving mobile shopping a huge boost. The company says it will offer a slew of app-only deals and two-hour delivery on certain items through the holiday. Customers can mark the deals they’re most excited about using a feature called “Watch a Deal,” which pushes a notification to their smartphones once the offer is live.

Taken together, Amazon seems to be saying it knows all about your impending Black Friday misery—and that it can really and truly relieve you of it. “Customers can truly sit back and relax with their family and friends this holiday season knowing that they will be notified as soon as the products they’ve had their eye on are about to go on sale,” Steve Shure, Amazon’s vice president of consumer marketing, said in a statement.

But Amazon is onto something bigger. It’s a pivotal time in the company's history, which makes scrutinizing Amazon's Black Friday strategy even more interesting. After enduring years of razor-thin profits—and even some losses—as the company poured money into building out distribution centers and logistics, it finally looks to be reaping the benefits. Don’t be surprised if 2015 is the tipping point where the world’s largest online retailer makes a lasting mark on the shopping holiday.

“You can’t generate that same kind of excitement if you’re trying to do this in-store,” says Ben Schachter, a Wall Street analyst at Macquarie, who specializes in Amazon. “Consumers aren’t going to be there every day for eight days. That’s not to say they can’t try to replicate customer success online, but Amazon is dominating online.”

Amazon’s Winning Strategy

Let’s not forget what’s on the backend here. Apart from Amazon’s formidable infrastructure—now comprised of about 173 facilities worldwide, by analysts' calculations—the company has learned from lessons of the past and created 100,000 temporary jobs to help it meet its holiday retail goals this season. That extra assistance should also help the company deliver purchased gifts to recipients reliably, something it had trouble with after a late surge in holiday sales last year.

It’s not even the first time Amazon has been able to spur sales without an official holiday. Earlier in the summer, to celebrate its 20th year anniversary, Amazon hosted Prime Day, an online sales event that it said would eclipse all other Black Friday promotions it had held in the past. In spite of shoppers being disappointed at what they thought was a lot of junk posted on the site, Amazon’s sales soared. According to the company, it did see more orders—398 of them per second, in fact—than any other Black Friday in its history.

The fact that the company has this ability to capture attention dovetails nicely with consumer holiday behavior. According to eMarketer’s research, year-round gift buying has now made the core holiday shopping season in November to December less important. About 48 percent of US shoppers had finished the majority of their 2014 shopping by Cyber Monday, up from 40 percent in 2013, according to a post-holiday survey by Ipsos MediaCT. And one-fourth of shoppers had already begun to shop for the holidays even before Halloween, the survey said.

“If consumers think that they’re getting some good deals, and some special deals even several days before Thanksgiving, I think Amazon could change some of their shopping habits in a way that very few other retailers could do,” says eMarketer retail analyst Yoram Wurmser. “I think they’re really trying to change the landscape with things like Prime Day and these eight days of Black Friday.” According to Wurmser, Amazon is still far ahead of its other online competitors, such as the discount-oriented startup Jet.com or the electronics-focused Newegg. Other retail giants like Walmart and Target, meanwhile, have been disappointing analysts and struggling to keep pace with Amazon’s hyper-efficiency when it comes to shorter delivery times and rock-bottom costs.

Even holiday favorites like department stores Macy’s and Nordstrom are taking a hit, with their latest earnings showing declines. The irony is that transaction values are actually up overall, according to data from RetailNext cited by eMarketer—and sales will probably be up this holiday season, too. But foot traffic is clearly dropping—probably because shoppers are going straight to these physical stores with a mission after doing their research online. “I expect to see Black Friday probably be not as much of an event [in brick-and-mortar stores] as it used to be,” says Wurmser. “People are going more for experiences rather than products. I think that’s having an effect on some of these traditional retailers as well.”

The Web and Mobile Matter

Mobile commerce is also still on the rise. This year, most social networks—including Facebook, Twitter, and Pinterest—have either tested or introduced Buy Buttons. Meanwhile, data from comScore shows that mobile commerce tends to spike during the fourth quarter. So it makes sense that Amazon too is escalating its mobile efforts this holiday shopping season.

The fact that so many people are now starting their product searches online is another factor in Amazon’s favor. In a recent survey from Survata, 44 percent of respondents searching for products online went directly to Amazon, while 34 percent used search engines like Google and Bing, and 21 percent browsed a specific retailer’s site. “Amazon’s scale has almost made it the de facto shopping search engine,” Wurmser says. Not to mention a little feature of the Amazon mobile app—Price Check—that has long been used by shoppers to make sure they’re getting the best deal possible from brick-and-mortar stores—the so-called showrooming effect.

All of which just shows that Amazon has found all sorts of ways to pull consumers into its world, something that could make a huge impact this Black Friday holiday—and help it secure its lead among its many challengers. “I don’t think Amazon is trying to get out ahead of its competitors. I think they are ahead,” says Wurmser. “They’re not playing defensively so much as offensively.” Amazon isn't just winning Black Friday shopping. It's undermining the holiday completely.